My TBR List is still mostly TBR
Feb. 28th, 2024 06:50 pmI guess four isn't all that bad, really.
But, okay, so last week, I read two gender and sexuality related manga (one fictionalized the other autobiographical): Last Gender: When We Are Nameless by Take Rei and At 30, I Realized I Had No Gender by Arai Shou. Last Gender takes place in a fictional sex bar in California where sexual and gender minorities meet, mingle, and (occasionally have sex.) I reviewed this on my manga review site and got off on a couple tangents, one of which was about how I am often amused when Japanese mangaka attempt to write about America or Britain. It is clear that California is known throughout the world as some kind free love, sex paradise, because, while I know things like swinger clubs exist, the idea that there is a bar that a person could just walk into off the street like this anywhere in the US seems... well, fantastical. But, this is a fantasy, so I will let them have it. And who am I to say? Perhaps I am being unfair to the great state of California. Perhaps it is just my small-minded Minnesota self that can't imagine this would be even vaguely legal. Anyway! The manga is fun? It does this sort of serial thing where a character introduced in the background of one chapter, will get to be the star of the next.... and each of these characters comes from a unique gender or sexual background. I got introduced to lithosexuality which was a new one for me, and because each story is dramatized, everyone is sympathetic, There are several volumes, but it's a quick read.
The second one, At 30, I Realized I Had No Gender is obviously the autobiographical one. However, the story is not as "on the tin." I mean, wouldn't you assume, with a title like that, that the story you'd get would be Arai-sensei journey of self-discovery? The manga is clearly presented long after the fact. The whole thing reads like, "As you know, Bob... " (where I have no idea) "... and, that's been my life since! And now I'm growing old! Oh no!"
I felt very left out of the story? In fact, it seems pretty clear that we are supposed to already be very, very. VERY well aware of Arai-sensei's entire life story as there is a reference to the documentary about his life.
Not having seen the documentary, I read the whole manga with a lot of questions rolling around in my head. For instance, Arai-sensei used the term intersex and non-binary sort of interchangeably, to the point that I started to wonder if intersex was how the Japanese referred to non-binary folx--but, no, it turns out, I found out from Baka-Updates (of all places), that he* has Turner Syndrome. (He is the pronoun that was used in the manga and which Arai-sensei was using at the time, just to add to my confusion. It seems, in the documentary that Arai uses no pronouns, which is possible in Japanese, but not so much in English.)
I feel like I would not recommend this, like, at all, unless a person was already familiar with Arai-sensei's life story. I haven't yet reviewed it for my manga site because I fear that I'm going to be the only manga reviewer in existence that hit this book expecting something else and has something other than heaps of praise for it. Because, the other thing that ended up bothering me about is that a seriously large portion of it focuses heavily on Arai-sensei's obsession with his looks. He's very focused on growing old and what that's doing to his body and then, another giant section of the book is about how having lost weight makes him feel about his body... and then there are weird snippets where he gives advice to other people who have issues with their looks. I fully accept that this is a big issue for the trans and intersex communities, but, as someone who has her own body issues, I really had a hard time when Arai-sensei was very explicitly like, "if you're fat and masc, you look like this and that looks AWFUL! Don't do this!!" and then draws a picture of my exact body and haircut in the clothes I tend to wear in order to ridicule it.
And I was like, okay, wow,
So, yeah, this book did not work for me on a lot of levels.
After that, I needed a palette cleanser and so read two fluff pieces, Volume 20 of What Did You Eat Yesterday? by Yoshinaga Fumi and The Secret, Evil Society of Cats by Pandania. I have nothing to say about either of these because they were fun and delightful and exactly what I needed.
What about you? Read anything interesting?